INDIANAPOLIS,
IN (August 16, 2001) - In a nationwide survey of high
school sports officials conducted online by the National
Federation of State High School Associations (NFHS),
career/job demands was cited as the most frequent reason
that men and women leave the avocation of high school
officiating.
Of
the 463 respondents to the survey, all of whom had resigned
as active officials in their respective states, 167
listed career/job demands as one of the reasons that
they left officiating. Other top reasons cited by the
former officials were poor sportsmanship by participants
(105), poor sportsmanship by spectators (96), time away
from family/friends (84) and low game fees (83).
All
sports were included in the survey, but basketball,
football, volleyball, soccer, baseball and softball
officials responded most often. Demands from their jobs
or careers was the most frequent response by officials
in all sports. Poor sportsmanship by spectators ranked
second in basketball, football, soccer and softball.
Volleyball officials ranked time away from family/friends
as the No. 2 reason, while baseball umpires cited low
game fees as their second most frequent reason for leaving
officiating.
In
the breakdown between male and female respondents, females
who had left the avocation of officiating ranked time
away from family and friends much higher than the male
respondents, although both males and females cited career/job
demands as the top reason.
The
survey also looked at years of experience by those leaving
the officiating ranks. Of the 463 respondents, 249 dropped
out of officiating after 10 years or less. Although
career/job demands was still a prominent reason that
this group listed for leaving officiating, the 102 respondents
in the range of six to 10 years of experience cited
poor sportsmanship by participants and poor sportsmanship
by spectators as the top two reasons they chose to leave
officiating.
The
respondents who left officiating with more than 25 years
of experience cited voluntary retirement and personal
health as the main reasons they ended their officiating
careers.
"I
think most people expected poor sportsmanship to be
the top reason why people were leaving the officiating
ranks, so we were a little bit surprised that career/job
demands was the chief reason across the board,"
said Mary Struckhoff, NFHS assistant director and staff
liaison to the National Federation Officials Association.
"There is not a lot we can do to impact problems
that officials have with regard to career/job demands,
so our focus needs to be on sportsmanship issues, which
overall was the No. 2 reason listed by the respondents.
"The
breakdown by years of experience will be very helpful
as we develop our NFHS Officials Education Program.
We will also be working with high school athletic administrators
in an attempt to improve sportsmanship at high school
athletic events. Improving the level of sportsmanship
is a complex issue, because there are so many different
groups of individuals involved, but we will continue
to work with athletic directors nationwide through the
National Interscholastic Athletic Administrators Association."
The
survey was conducted via the NFHS Web site (nfhs.org),
and several state high school associations sent out
the Web address to targeted officials who had resigned
from officiating. The survey is still available on the
NFHS Web site, and Struckhoff said the NFHS will continue
to seek more feedback on this subject as the Officials
Education Program is developed and implemented across
the country.
|